A Tree Grows in Brooklyn
Betty Smith
We may earn a commission on purchases — at no cost to you. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Disclosure.
A Tree Grows in Brooklyn is Betty Smith's tender, unflinching novel about Francie Nolan, a poor girl growing up in Brooklyn at the turn of the twentieth century, who finds solace and escape in reading. Told with humour, heartbreak and unsentimental compassion for her struggling family, the novel traces Francie's path from childhood poverty through adolescence toward adulthood, showing how love, education and the act of reading reshape a life. It is a masterpiece of American realism and the particular art of survival in working-class life.
- 1Francie Nolan lives in extreme poverty in Brooklyn with her alcoholic father Johnny, her hardworking mother Katie, and her brother Neeley.
- 2From early childhood Francie escapes into books, reading everything she can find and imagining herself into other worlds.
- 3Her father Johnny is a charming but unreliable man who loves Francie deeply but is unable to provide; his death is the novel's emotional pivot.
- 4Katie, Francie's mother, works ceaselessly as a janitor, and her practical ambition for her children's survival and advancement shapes Francie's understanding of duty.
- 5Francie's adolescence brings sexual awakening, first love with a boy named Lee Rhynes, and the complication of wanting both escape and belonging.
- 6By the novel's close, Francie has endured poverty, loss and humiliation, yet emerges with her love of learning intact and a sense of her own worth.
Key ideas
Reading as survival and transformation
Francie's books are her lifeline, the way she escapes her circumstances and educates herself when school is inadequate. Smith celebrates reading not as pretension but as a practical tool for survival and imagination, the way a poor child reaches beyond her immediate world.
The dignity of poverty
The Nolans live in conditions that would invite pity or sentimentality in lesser hands. Smith treats their poverty with unsentimental clarity: it is hard, humiliating and limiting, yet the family's love and humour persist. She refuses to make the poor tragic or pathetic; they are ordinary people managing extraordinary circumstances.
The unreliable beloved
Johnny Nolan is Francie's father and the love of her life, yet he is also irresponsible, drunk and unable to provide. His death comes early, but Smith makes clear that Francie has already absorbed his lessons: love is not the same as reliability, and those we love most may fail us.
Mothers and daughters
Katie and Francie's relationship is complex and full of tension. Katie's hardness and practicality seem to clash with Francie's dreams, but Francie gradually understands that her mother's single-minded focus on survival is itself an act of love, and she inherits her mother's strength.
The cost of adolescence
Smith renders the pain of adolescence without condescension: sexual awakening, shame, the desire to escape one's family, first love and its loss. Francie's youth is neither romanticised nor made grotesque; it is shown as genuinely difficult and formative.
American realism at its best
Smith's achievement is showing how ordinary lives have depth, dignity and weight. The novel refutes the idea that poverty must produce either tragedy or moral redemption; the Nolans are simply people, doing their best, with all the complexity that entails.
Who is it for?
Readers who love intimate, unsentimental portraits of working-class life and coming-of-age stories centred on a girl's interior world will find this profoundly moving. It rewards anyone interested in American realism, Brooklyn history, or the particular art of surviving poverty. Readers of Jeannette Walls or memoirs of working-class childhood will feel the kinship.
Full summary
Francie Nolan, born in 1902, grows up in the worst tenement neighbourhoods of Brooklyn with her parents and younger brother Neeley. Her father Johnny is a waiter and natural charmer, habitually drunk; her mother Katie is a janitor by trade and an iron-willed pragmatist by temperament.
From early childhood Francie finds her salvation in a nearby branch of the Brooklyn Public Library. She reads voraciously and indiscriminately, anything from Shakespeare to comic papers, using books to escape and educate herself. The act of reading is her most consistent pleasure and her door to another life.
The family exists in a state of chronic poverty. Katie works obsessively to keep them fed and housed, and her practical, often harsh devotion to survival means she and Francie clash repeatedly. Katie resents Francie's dreaming and book-addiction, seeing them as impractical luxuries.
Francie's father Johnny is beloved by Francie in a way that her mother never quite is. He is warm, musical and interested in Francie herself, yet he is also unreliable, drunk most days, and unable to provide for his family. He dies of pneumonia when Francie is still young, and his death removes a primary source of tenderness from her life.
As Francie enters adolescence she becomes aware of her body and of boys, and falls in love with a neighbourhood boy named Lee Rhynes. Their romance is Francie's first glimpse of romantic love and also of the possibility of escape, and when it ends in disappointment it is a real loss.
Katie's single-minded focus on the children's advancement pushes both Francie and Neeley toward schooling and away from the dead-end paths common in their neighbourhood. Francie sees this as her mother's coldness but gradually understands it as her form of love.
Francie also works, as all poor children did, taking jobs as a janitor's helper like her mother, as a silk mill worker and in other low positions. She earns money and sees the world of adult labour, which both hardens and educates her.
By the novel's close Francie, now older and preparing for education beyond the neighbourhood, has survived poverty, loss and the ordinary humiliations of being poor and female. She has kept her love of reading and her sense of her own worth, and though she is still uncertain of her future, she is no longer defeated by it.
